Lotion, cream or ointment

The names describe texture. Lotions are the thinnest and spread easily. Creams are thicker. Ointments are the heaviest and usually feel greasy. Thicker products generally contain less water and more oils or waxes, so a small jar of ointment can last longer than a similarly priced bottle of lotion. The right one depends on your skin, the season, and where on the body you apply it.

Reading a lotion label

  • Fragrance-free: no fragrance ingredients were added. Unscented can mean a masking ingredient, so check the list for fragrance or parfum.
  • Dye-free: no colorants were added.
  • Dermatologist-tested and hypoallergenic: hints, not guarantees. Hypoallergenic has no single legal definition in the United States.
  • For dry skin: a marketing category. It tells you what the maker is aiming at, not what will happen on your skin.
  • If a lotion lists an SPF, it is a sunscreen product and is regulated as an over-the-counter drug. See our mineral sunscreen guide, and read its Drug Facts panel.

Our angle: pumps, tubs and how fast you use them

A pump bottle gives a consistent dose, which makes your cost predictable. A tub is easy to scoop from but can be hard to keep clean, so check how the product is meant to be stored. Because thicker products contain less water, compare them by how long they last for you, not only by ounces. Track the date you open a container and the date it runs out, and divide the price by the weeks.

Comparing prices

  • Buy a small size first if your skin is sensitive.
  • Check the period after opening on the label, if there is one, before you buy in bulk.
  1. Find the ounces on the label and divide the price by it.
  2. Compare similar textures with each other: lotion with lotion, cream with cream.
  3. Compare refill pouches and large pumps with the small bottle, and check what the container is made of and whether it can be recycled where you live.

See also: mineral sunscreen · gentle face wash

More in Personal Care

See all in Gentle Essentials