Gentle fabric softener: fragrance-free labels and when to skip it

Liquid, sheets or balls

• Liquid softener: added to the rinse cycle, in the dispenser. Compare it by price per load.
• Dryer sheets: go in the dryer. Each sheet is one use, so the cost repeats on every load.
• Dryer balls: reusable. See our wool dryer balls guide for a break-even calculation.
• Skipping it: many people do not use any softener, and some people add a small amount of white vinegar to the rinse. Check your washer's manual before adding anything unusual.

Reading the label

• Free and clear, fragrance-free or dye-free: no added fragrance or colorants. Check the ingredient list.
• Unscented: can mean a masking ingredient. Check the list.
• HE and compatibility: check that it works in your machine.
• Hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested tell you something about how the maker positions the product, and little about how you will do with it.

Our angle: check the care label before you pour

Softener is not right for every item. Care labels on some garments, such as flame-resistant children's sleepwear and many moisture-wicking sportswear items, say not to use fabric softener, because it can leave a coating. Softener can also reduce how absorbent towels feel. If you follow the care labels, you may find that you use softener for only some loads, which lowers your real cost per load. Count the loads where you really use it, not every load, and divide the bottle price accordingly.

1. Read the care labels on children's sleepwear, sportswear and towels.
2. Divide the bottle price by the loads it gives you at the label's dose.
3. Count only the loads where you actually use softener.

Buying tips

• Use the amount on the label. More does not mean softer.
• Concentrated formulas are cheaper per load only if you use less.
• Try a small size before you buy in bulk, especially with sensitive skin.